Preiskel & CoPreiskel & Co
Preiskel & Co
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Diversity, Social Responsibility, and Pro Bono
  • Services
    • Corporate
    • Commercial
    • Regulatory
    • Competition & Antitrust
    • Data Protection, Privacy, and Retention
    • Intellectual Property
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Employment
  • Sectors
    • Telecommunications
    • IT, Technology, & Internet
    • Media and Broadcasting
    • Websites, Blogging, & Social Media
    • Film & Television
    • Gambling & Online Gaming
    • Leisure & Retail
    • Energy & Minerals
    • Cryptocurrency & Blockchain
    • Creative Industries
  • People
    • Daniel Preiskel
    • Ronnie Preiskel
    • Tim Cowen
    • Jose Saras
    • Robert Dougans
    • Karthyaeni Vittala
    • Tina Cowen
    • D A T Green
    • Richard Stewart
    • Mor Swiel
    • Ilanit Appelfeld
    • Stephen Dnes
    • Daniel Oakland
    • Robert Harvey
    • Martina Raciti
    • Joanna Coombs-Huang
    • Xavier Prida
    • Stewart White
    • Alison MacFarlane
    • Hannah Leader
    • Peter Dally
    • Antony Corel
    • Sue Warwick
    • Tony Curzon-Price
    • Shardi Shameli
    • Stephen Hornsby
    • Ewelina James
    • Maria Constantin
    • Sophia Yakhno
    • Rachael Machado
  • International
  • Blog
  • News
    • Publications
  • Contact
Menu back  

The Preiskel Blog

EU Net Neutrality Court Decision on Deutsche Telekom’s Zero-Rated StreamOn

November 29, 2018By Preiskel & Co

EU Net Neutrality Court Decision on Deutsche Telekom’s Zero-Rated StreamOn

Image of Deutsche Telekom logo by Marco Verch (Creative Commons license)

Image courtesy Marco Verch (Creative Commons license)

On 20 November the Administrative Court in Köln upheld an earlier 2017 decision by the Bundesnetzagentur (the Federal Network Agency) that Deutsche Telekom’s zero-rated “StreamOn” offer violated net neutrality regulations.

As Preiskel & Co Senior Partner and telecoms law expert Daniel Preiskel explained, “we found the court decision interesting and worth noting, especially as the use of zero-rating has been debated across Europe amongst mobile industry leaders, regulators and academics alike. This particular ruling was consistent with the advice we have been providing as to how zero-rated streaming offers can be structured in a way that is compatible with EU net neutrality rules.”

“Zero-rating” is the practice of not charging customers for data use when they access specific websites and services. Accordingly, zero rating plans can be used by internet service and mobile service providers to create more tempting limited data plans for customers while favoring their own, affiliate or popular sites. In this way, some websites and internet services are being treated differently and, in some circumstances, this can raise questions in respect of net neutrality.

With StreamOn, 1.7 million Deutsche Telekom customers are able to stream movies, series, sports or music through over 350 content partners. Initial concerns that the preferred treatment of certain platforms could harm net neutrality were thought to be circumvented by Telekom, by making participation in StreamOn free of charge for the content partners in question.

However, in 2017, the Federal Network Agency informed Deutsche Telekom that it would need to redesign its StreamOn offer in order to be compliant with the EU rules. Deutsche Telekom disagreed, and the regulator turned to the courts in Köln for legal clarification.

The court’s analysis turned on two important facts. Firstly, speeds were throttled to speeds below 1.7 Mbps for streaming. Secondly, the zero-rated data in question were not available outside of Germany (ie, when roaming elsewhere in the EU). Deutsche Telekom had argued that the StreamOn offer was “voluntary,” but the court found that customers could not in fact opt out of the service.

Deutsche Telekom may appeal the decision to the Oberverwaltungsgericht (the Higher Administrative Court for North Rhine-Westphalia) in Münster. We consider this avenue is likely to be followed, noting that a company spokesperson stated that Deutsche Telekom “will continue to make use of all legal possibilities so that StreamOn can continue to be offered.”

The decision is grounded in the interpretation of the EU’s Open Internet Access Regulation 2015/2120 of 25 November 2015, commonly known as “the Net Neutrality Regulation.” You can find the original press release from the Court here.

If you have any questions about zero-rating, net neutrality, or other aspects of internet and communications law, please contact Daniel Preiskel or Jose Saras.

commercialEU lawispmobilenet neutralityzero rating
Latest Preiskel & Co blog posts
  • White House’s Economic Report of the President sets out a roadmap to improve competition in digital markets
    March 22, 2023
  • Brussels Conference brings in industry leaders to discuss the international antitrust landscape
    March 22, 2023
  • Issues in the UK’s forthcoming Digital Markets, Competition and Consumer Bill
    March 17, 2023
  • Stormy weather for cloud computing in the EU
    March 16, 2023
  • Inmarsat Takeover Provisionally Cleared for Take-Off
    March 10, 2023
  • EDPB’s Feedback on the New EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework
    March 6, 2023
  • UK Data Reform Bill to return to the House of Commons
    March 3, 2023
  • DCMS Publishes New Security and Privacy Principles for App Store Operators and Developers
    February 16, 2023
  • DPO’s Dismissal & Conflicts of Interest Under The EU GDPR – CJEU Ruling
    February 14, 2023
  • ICO – Change of Deadline for Reporting Breach Notifications for Communication Service Providers
    February 6, 2023
  • General EU Requirements for Cookie Banners – EDPB Task Force Report
    January 27, 2023
  • Ofcom Launches Investigation into BT Following Suspected Breaches of Consumer Protections Post Implementation of EECC
    January 27, 2023

The Preiskel Blog

  • White House’s Economic Report of the President sets out a roadmap to improve competition in digital markets 22 Mar 2023
  • Brussels Conference brings in industry leaders to discuss the international antitrust landscape 22 Mar 2023
  • Issues in the UK’s forthcoming Digital Markets, Competition and Consumer Bill 17 Mar 2023
  • Stormy weather for cloud computing in the EU 16 Mar 2023

Preiskel news

  • Senior Partner, Danny Preiskel, quoted by IT Pro on the costs incurred by MNOs
  • Senior Partner, Danny Preiskel, will be a panellist at GCCM Carrier Community 2023 on IOT
  • Jose Saras and Xavier Prida Awarded First Place as Data Protection Thought Leaders in the UK
  • Ronnie Preiskel chosen to judge 24 May 2023 The Tech Capital Global Awards
Preiskel tweets
  • White House’s Economic Report of the President sets out a roadmap to improve competition in digital markets. Find o… https://t.co/S7J7sX3kfs5 hours ago
  • Brussels Conference brings in industry leaders to discuss the international antitrust landscape. Find out more at: https://t.co/JN5P4COQ4f6 hours ago
  • Stormy weather for cloud computing in the EU. Find out more at: https://t.co/dOpC8u4wLf6 days ago
Preiskel & Co LLP
4 King's Bench Walk,
Temple,
London
EC4Y 7DL
United Kingdom

Tel: +44 20 7332 5640
Email: info@preiskel.com

Find us on:

TwitterLinkedinMail
© Preiskel & Co LLP 2023 | Site map | Legal notices | Cookie Policy | Privacy