Preiskel & CoPreiskel & Co
Preiskel & Co
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Diversity, Social Responsibility, and Pro Bono
  • Services
    • Corporate
    • Commercial
    • Regulatory
    • Competition & Antitrust
    • Data Protection, Privacy, and Retention
    • Intellectual Property
    • Dispute Resolution
    • Employment
  • Sectors
    • Telecommunications
    • IT, Technology, & Internet
    • Media and Broadcasting
    • Websites, Blogging, & Social Media
    • Film & Television
    • Gambling & Online Gaming
    • Leisure & Retail
    • Energy & Minerals
    • Cryptocurrency & Blockchain
    • Creative Industries
  • People
    • Daniel Preiskel
    • Ronnie Preiskel
    • Tim Cowen
    • Jose Saras
    • Robert Dougans
    • Tina Cowen
    • D A T Green
    • Karthyaeni Vittala
    • Mor Swiel
    • Ilanit Appelfeld
    • Charles Soden-Bird
    • Nick Bromfield
    • Stephen Dnes
    • Daniel Oakland
    • Robert Harvey
    • Martina Raciti
    • Matthew Fox
    • Joanna Coombs-Huang
    • Xavier Prida
    • Mark Clough
    • Stewart White
    • Hannah Leader
    • Peter Dally
    • Antony Corel
    • Sue Warwick
    • Galyna Carey
    • Stephen Hornsby
    • Claire Barraclough
  • International
  • Blog
  • News
    • Publications
  • Contact
Menu back  

First Ever Shareholder Class Action in England & Wales Dismissed

November 21, 2019By Preiskel & Co

The first shareholder class action claim to be brought before the English courts, Sharp v Blank [2019] EWHC 3078 (Ch) has been dismissed from the High Court of Justice Chancery Division. The claim, which is on behalf of over 5,000 Lloyds shareholders, is against Lloyds and five former directors. It relates to Lloyds’ 2008 acquisition of HBOS.

Essentially, the claim was brought on two alternative grounds:

  1. that the directors were negligent to recommend that shareholders approve the acquisition in a circular prior to an Extraordinary General meeting; and
  2. that the circular itself with made negligent misstatements or failed to disclose material information.

It was alleged that, the shareholders would not have approved the acquisition of HBOS, but for the directors’ recommendation and/or that had they had disclosure of the relevant material facts they would not have allowed the acquisition to go ahead.

The High Court ruled against the shareholders on both grounds. In respect of the first ground, it was found that the directors had acted in a manner in which a reasonably competent director of such a bank could act. A notable element of the court findings emphasized that in the circumstance when a director honestly holds the belief that a proposal is in the best interests of the company then the claimant has the burden of showing that no reasonably competent director could have reached that view. Directors are also to be comforted by the obiter that they are entitled to rely on the advice of professional advisers unless there is obvious error in that advice. Interestingly, in respect of the second ground, the Court found that shareholders should have been informed of HBOS’ use of emergency funding from the Bank of England, and of a £1 billion loan facility from Lloyds, but the Court was not satisfied that the shareholders would not have prevented the transaction even if such disclosure had taken place. Therefore,

There have been calls for the increased use of class action claims, a type of claim more commonly seen in the US, than in the English courts. The High Court’s decision in this case highlights that such claims are subject to particular hurdles, and may serve to dampen that enthusiasm, at least in relation to class action claims on behalf of shareholders.

Please contact Ronnie Preiskel should you have any questions regarding the above.

Latest blog posts
  • CMA publishes Issues Statement in Liberty Global/Telefónica merger inquiry
    January 22, 2021
  • Epic Games, creator of Fortnite, launches claims against Google and Apple in Competition Appeal Tribunal
    January 21, 2021
  • European Commission proposal for Digital Services Act published
    December 15, 2020
  • Facebook faces antitrust lawsuits in the US
    December 11, 2020
  • CMA issues advice for Government on regulatory regime for tech giants
    December 10, 2020
  • New Telecoms Security Law Laid before Parliament for tougher Rules and Fines for Telecoms Companies
    November 25, 2020
  • New Ofcom Consultation on Copper Retirement
    November 23, 2020
  • European Commission releases draft new Standard Contractual Clauses
    November 19, 2020
  • National Security and Investment Bill published
    November 16, 2020
  • Inherited GDPR breach still leads to a record fine for Marriott
    November 3, 2020
  • UK National Data Strategy: a step further away from an adequacy decision under the GDPR?
    October 21, 2020
  • British Airways issued £20 million fine by ICO for data breach
    October 20, 2020
The Preiskel Blog
  • CMA publishes Issues Statement in Liberty Global/Telefónica merger inquiry 22 Jan 2021
  • Epic Games, creator of Fortnite, launches claims against Google and Apple in Competition Appeal Tribunal 21 Jan 2021
  • European Commission proposal for Digital Services Act published 15 Dec 2020
  • Facebook faces antitrust lawsuits in the US 11 Dec 2020
Preiskel news
  • Tim Cowen and Claire Barraclough co-author article published in Competition Policy International
  • Electric Car Batteries with 5 min charging times produced
  • Tim Cowen to deliver Oxford lecture on 12 February 2021
  • CMA announces investigation into Google Privacy Sandbox
Preiskel tweets
  • We're delighted to see @CompPolicyInt publish an article co-authored by P&Co's @TC_4KBW and @ClaireBarraclo4. You c… https://t.co/XoeKtg3dI82 hours ago
  • The @CMAGovUK has published its Issues Statement in Liberty Global/Telefónica merger inquiry. More details here:… https://t.co/D9P8LuRyxU5 days ago
  • Creator of Fortnite, @EpicGames, launches claims against @Google and @Apple in @CATribunal. Contact @TC_4KBW with q… https://t.co/IjzXiFO2fF6 days ago
Preiskel & Co LLP
4 King's Bench Walk,
Temple,
London
EC4Y 7DL
United Kingdom

Tel:
+44 20 7332 5640
Email:
info@preiskel.com

Find us on:

TwitterLinkedinMail
© Preiskel & Co LLP 2021 | Site map | Legal notices | Privacy | Cookie Policy

   

We use essential and analytic cookies on our website. By continuing to use our site, you are agreeing to the use of cookies as set in our Cookie Policy. OKCookie policy